Creatine has had a strange couple of years. For two decades it sat in the gym bag of teenage boys and footy players and now it keeps coming up at school pickup, in mums’ Facebook groups and on the shelves of pharmacies in Bondi Junction that never used to stock it. Plenty of women in their thirties and forties are hearing about it from a physio or a GP rather than a personal trainer, which is a fairly new development.
That raises two reasonable questions. What does it do for someone who isn’t training for a grand final? And does it make you put on weight? The second one stops more women than anything else, so it’s worth answering both properly.
What creatine does
Your body makes creatine on its own and stores nearly all of it in your muscles, where it helps cells recharge quickly during short hard efforts. Lifting a pram up the stairs, chasing a toddler across Queens Park, getting out of a low chair with a sleeping baby on you. Food tops the stores up too, mostly from red meat and fish.
Supplementing fills those stores to a level food alone doesn’t reach. On average women carry smaller baseline stores than men do. Eat little red meat and the starting point drops further. That goes some way to explaining why studies keep finding the effects show up at least as clearly in women. The dose that does this is small. A flat teaspoon, about three grams, maybe five, stirred into water or a smoothie, taken whenever suits. The old loading phase with big doses several times a day isn’t needed. Stores fill up over three or four weeks either way.
Picking one if you decide to try it
The right form hasn’t moved since the nineties. Almost every study worth reading used plain creatine monohydrate and it happens to be the cheapest form on the shelf. The fancier versions on the market cost more without outperforming it. When comparing creatine supplement options the things worth checking are that it’s plain monohydrate, that the label lists creatine as the only ingredient or close to it and the price per serve rather than per tub. A plain unflavoured one disappears into anything.
Does creatine cause weight gain?
The scales can move, so let’s be exact about what moves them. Creatine draws water into muscle cells along with it. During the first few weeks many people see somewhere between half a kilo and a kilo appear. That extra weight is water sitting inside muscle, not fat. It settles there and stays fairly stable for as long as you keep taking it.
Nothing about creatine adds body fat. It carries no kilojoules to speak of. Some women notice nothing on the scales at all and the ones who do usually find the number steadies within a month. If a small shift in scale weight would bother you more than it’s worth, that’s a fair reason to skip the whole thing. If what you care about is how you feel and function, it’s a non-issue.
Why midlife is where the interest is
The newer research that’s driving all this conversation mostly concerns women approaching and past menopause. As oestrogen falls, muscle and bone density both start a slow decline and strength training is the most reliable way to push back. Creatine appears to hand that training a little extra to work with. Studies that paired it with regular resistance work over a year or more found a bit more lean muscle held onto and somewhat better bone outcomes than training alone. The effects are modest and they depend on the training actually happening.
There’s also a line of research on the brain, covering memory and mental tiredness in stressed or sleep-deprived people, where women who supplemented tended to hold up slightly better. Interesting, but early. Jean Hailes has a thorough plain-language overview of menopause and the muscle and bone changes that come with it, which is useful background whether or not supplements ever enter the picture.
When you don’t need it
Anyone eating red meat or fish several times a week already keeps their stores reasonably topped up and will notice less from supplementing. If you’re pregnant or breastfeeding the sensible move is to run any supplement past your GP first, since that’s simply not where the research has been done. Teenagers get more from food, sleep and training habits than from any powder. And if you’re not doing some kind of strength work, creatine has much less to act on, so the money is better spent fixing that first.
None of this is urgent either. Creatine will still be there in six months and it will still be cheap.
Starting without overthinking it
A sensible start looks like three grams a day with breakfast, every day including the days you do nothing, for a month before you judge anything. Pair it with something that loads your muscles twice a week or so, whether that’s a gym program, a kettlebell at home or working your way up to running with the locals at the Gunyama Run Club. Keep expectations at the level the research supports. A little more in the tank on hard days, slightly better returns from the training you were doing anyway and a number on the scales that might sit half a kilo higher for entirely boring reasons.


